LEAFS ROUNDTABLE: Life of Rie

Justin Fisher
December 07 2013 11:36AM

 

The TLN Roundtable is back! Every week, we'll pose a Leafs-related question to our writers, gather the various opinions, post the answers, and create internal tension and hatred amongst us. Then you, the reader, get to tell us how wrong we are in the comments!
 
This week's question...

Should Morgan Rielly be loaned to Canada's World Junior team?

JUSTIN FISHER

I think that Rielly should be allowed to go. As good as he's been so far this season, Rielly's absence wouldn't be the reason why the Leafs would lose games while he's gone. Also, Rielly has only suited up for 22 of the Leafs' 29 games so far - he's sitting out every fourth game. Would the Leafs really be significantly worse with another defender in his place? Hell, they beat Dallas without him in the lineup. Rielly is going to be a star one day, but he's not a game-breaker at this point in his career.
 
It'd also just be fun to watch him dominate. By my estimation, Rielly would be Team Canada's top defenceman, a shoe-in for a leadership role, and the quarterback of what should be one of the tournament's top power plays. Maybe this is a little too romantic a thought, but would Rielly not benefit long-term from a gold medal run? Would he not gain confidence from being one of the best players on the ice? It certainly wouldn't hurt to send him to Malmo and find out.

STEVE DANGLE

You know what? Yes, the Leafs should let Rielly go.
 
If anything, this will give the Leafs a chance to do the right thing and call up John-Michael Liles, which they did. They can showcase him, and if he gets dealt it's a big relief on the cap. That or he'll be really good and they can keep him, although Randy Carlyle has "already made up his mind" on Liles according to Bob McKenzie. Hell, recall T.J. Brennan or Stuart Percy and see what they're made of. Anything but this Fraser-Ranger pairing right now. It's a tire fire. I would never wish an injury on anybody, and Tyler Bozak hasn't been bad this season, but it took a long-term injury to Bozak for Kadri to finally get his shot with the top line. What's the saying? "Necessity is the mother of invention." Not having Rielly for a few weeks might allow the Leafs to discover a gem within their own system, or at very least help them realize how much they miss Rielly.

RYAN FANCEY

I think Rielly should definitely stay with the Leafs because they can afford better equipment, particularly helmets. If he goes to this youth tournament everyone keeps talking about, Doctor Carlyle can't monitor his brain temperature and I feel like that's an unnecessary risk considering he's such a promising prospect for the Leafs. If he runs into concussion troubles, I really don't want to be the guy to say "I told you so" but we'll see how it all plays out. 

C0293e2b4678f1e929600607efbd5b6b
Justin Fisher is The Leafs Nation's Managing Editor. After the game, he's a handsome vigilante who fights crime and frequents late night food trucks.
Avatar
#1 Ammar Hussain
December 07 2013, 01:59PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
2
props

As much as I want Rielly to play for Team Canada, but if he does play for team Canada that means more ice time/games for Ranger and Fraser, which scares me

Avatar
#2 STAN
December 07 2013, 12:10PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
3
props

Nice discussion. Are we even sure Rielly has been invited? I thought I read that he hadn't been,

Nonetheless, Steve's point about Carlyle already making up his mind about Liles is right on the mark. There's ample evidence to suggest Randy Carlyle is one of those people who makes snap judgements and has a stubborn streak comparable to Brian Burke's.

Perhaps that's acceptable, but why should a GM (Nonis) blindly follow his subordinate's opinion without using his own eyes? And I think, if you read some of my other posts, you now here this is going.

MacArthur, Grabovski, Liles, Frattin and Komarov.

Now, there's likely no empirical evidence that Carlyle strongly suggested all of these guys were drags on the team and easily replaceable. But is sure looks that way.

Putting aside the insane decision to pay Grabbo to play for someone else, why on Earth would you just let MacArhur walk? For NOTHING? He's got superior numbers to David '"Mister Millstone' Clarkson, right across the board.

The contributions of Frattin and Komarov were grossly underestimated. Neither guy was a goat in that epic Game 7 collapse last year. Their speed and willingness to take the body is sorely missed this season.

Grabbo. Grabbbo. Grabbo. If only SOMEONE in the Leafs hierarchy had only had the nuts to suggest he was miscast and could be a VERY effective and productive guy in the role for which he's suited. Or did all those useless buddies Burke brought in as his leadership team all play sycophant to Nonis, and Nonis to Carlyle?

Makes one wonder what's going on within the Leafs division of MLSE.

Comments are closed for this article.