November 24 News and Notes


The quarter pole has arrived in the NHL season, and News and Notes is back to examine the state of affairs around the Nation and the league. In this episode, the Flames head for the bottom, the Oilers bounce back, and hockey’s best rejoins the action.


Well, where to begin? Last night’s effort in Detroit might seem better from a score POV, but the team was badly outplayed and is rapidly approaching the point of no return for the year, irrespective of whatever impassioned pleas might be emanating from the boss. I would encourage anyone that hasn’t listened to Brent Sutter’s Tuesday presser to do so, because it isn’t often that we hear any NHL coach so clearly demonstrate they’re at the end of their rope. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The sad truth is there might not be much left for the Flames to do but run out the season before starting over next summer. There’s no realistic likelihood of any team taking on the Flames’ lousy players, and moving the bigger salaries like Iginla or Bouwmeester, if that’s part of the plan, might need to wait until teams have more flexibility in the off-season.

Simply flushing a season is a pretty unappetizing prospect, especially for the STHs that keep this enterprise afloat, but the primary goal has to be resisting the temptation to take on contracts with any term attached in a fruitless attempt to salvage the year. 


A scroungy effort in Dallas earlier in the week was followed by an excellent performance in Nashville, as Edmonton continues on their road swing through the midwest. The Preds are in a bad way at the moment, as last night’s horrible performance in Minny showed, but the Oil were superb in getting Nashville out of their comfort zone in their own building. Dennis King’s scoring chance count had Edmonton at 9-0 after one, which is the type of play that will get your team a win most nights.

The Oiler wins over Chicago and the Predators have calmed the waters for the moment, but they still have the look of a team that will need a couple of defenders before they can begin to seriously consider the post-season. I’m not entirely convinced a team routinely dressing Theo Peckham won’t hit a slippery patch, in other words.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

That noted, the Oilers are on the road to becoming a good team, so the world should be a relatively happy place, irrespective of what dimwits might think. Colin Cowherd has made a very nice living being both loud and wrong without fail, so maybe I’m the one that’s missing the point, but it’s hard to argue that he has anything but a long history of ignorance on any number of subjects.



The Dys played a very quiet game in Colorado last night, doing an excellent job of suppressing the Avs until a string of penalties in the third forced the Canucks to play a bit of defence. From the outside, Vancouver still has the air of a team running in place after last season’s highs, although the underlying numbers are still very good

The Canucks might also just be feeling a bit of fortune’s reversal in terms of the percentages. They’ve certainly been a good team over the last few years, but they’ve also had a nice run of bounces along the way. Vancouver’s team 5v5 PDOs since 08/09 read 102.0, 101.7, 101.9, and it wasn’t just the Sedins magically driving things, since guys like Malhotra, Wellwood and Bernier were also well over 100 in that period.

This year, they sit at 98.1, and the Sedins are the only players on the high side. 98.1 is a bit low, however, and guys like Kesler and Booth will likely start to see things head north soon enough. 

They’ll also benefit from the return of Mason Raymond, who appears to be a bit ahead of schedule after his back surgery this summer. He’s another nice player to add to the arsenal, and should permit Vigneault at some juncture to harness Higgins and Malhotra as a full time duo against the toughs, with all others reaping the benefits.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below


The Leafs have managed to remain afloat in the face of a daunting run of injuries despite some mediocre outshooting numbers, mostly thanks to the hot sticks of Lupul and Kessel, but in fairness to that club, any team without their hard minutes center, two other useful forwards and their best goalie would be up against it. 

This morning does bring some good news in that regard, as James Reimer is back practicing with the club in Dallas. Gustavsson and Scrivens have been OK in the last few games, but Reimer’s presence is likely the difference between a team with a sniff at the post-season and one that might end up 11th or 12th in the East. If the Leafs can survive the next few weeks until they get their injured forwards back, we could see them stabilize that spot in the top eight. 


The Jets stole a point last night, getting outshot and outchanced in DC before falling in overtime 4-3. The lack of forward depth is one failing that good teams can expose when Winnipeg is on the road, and last night was a prime example, as Jaffray didn’t play after the second and Burmistrov and Thorburn sat for good chunks of the third. Scott covered a good chunk of the waterfront this morning on the club, and I’m mostly in accord.

The Buff to forward thing, well, I’ll just say again that people that watched the Hawks in the playoffs versus Vancouver are neglecting to note how ineffective he was the other 90 games or so in 08/09 and 09/10 when he played up front and leave it there. If the Jets don’t want him at D, they need to trade him, because his contract has no chance of being decent value if he works as a middling RW.

Overall, I’m really not entirely sold on Noel’s utilization of his players to this point. I don’t doubt that he recognizes the shallow, and callow, nature of his team up front, but Burmistrov likely deserved a better fate than playing seven minutes last night, since his overall game wasn’t terrible. He likely rates more PP time than he’s getting as well.

The other move that seems destined to fail in the end is the tendency to hard match Slater, Thorburn and Glass versus the toughs. Glass and Slater are sporting EVSH% north of 11 thus far, and there’s nothing in their games that hints at that being the norm, so a correction is almost certainly on its way.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

That noted, the fact that the Jets have been competitive 5v5 while spending most of the year away from home and sporting an overall 99.5 PDO does indicate that something is working, particularly in light of the fact that Winnipeg has used 12 different D in the first 21 games. Two of their better EV defenders have missed significant time, and in that vein, it was good to see Ron Hainsey back after missing 5 weeks.

He’s a slight upgrade from Arturs Kulda, and he jumped right back in the deep end, playing over 23 minutes against a strong team. That might be a timely return in another way, as word escaped this morning that Zach Bogosian has a date with Principal Shanahan to discuss his hit on Cody Eakin. 



After the expected shenanigans to start, the Bruins ground the Sabres down last night, winning in a shootout on Benoit Pouliot’s one meaningful contribution for the evening. The Bs have improved their underlying numbers dramatically this season, although the overloaded nature of their schedule has played a part in making them seem better.

The Bruins have played 7 games away from TD Garden, and as Steve Burtch showed this morning, they aren’t the same team on the road, small sample size and all. They have a run-in with the Wings tomorrow and a date in Pittsburgh on December 5th, and both of those games will be worth watching, to say the least.

Speaking of the Pens, Sid’s triumphant return versus the Islanders had people talking, but the Blues are made of sterner stuff, and his control of matters wasn’t nearly as complete on a night where St. Louis had Pittsburgh under pressure from the first period onward. Adrenaline is a crazy thing, and that boost almost certainly helped him along in his first game, but even an exemplar like Crosby might need a few more games before he’s really on track.

One team that has jumped out in dramatic fashion is Florida, and to this point, it’s largely on merit. They roasted the Rangers last night, outshooting them 38-20 on the way to a win. The Panthers have been strong both home and away, and they’ve done so in large part because Versteeg, Fleischmann and Weiss are outshooting the toughs.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

That stipulated, those three guys are riding some crazy percentages, especially on the SH% side of things. A fall back to more normal figures seems inevitable at some point, but Versteeg’s overall numbers are particularly strong even when accounting for the bounces. He’s finally healthy after a season suffering through a hernia problem, and having watched him a couple of times this year, his speed is obviously back to the level he had in Chicago. 



The sale of the Stars has been finalized, as Tom Gaglardi has assumed control of the bankrupt franchise. Despite a fairly extended history of success and a good beginning to building the grassroots of the game in Texas, Dallas is still susceptible to the same dangers that threaten other non-traditional markets. A few years of not making the playoffs and not marketing the club has driven attendance down to the depths, and as James Mirtle’s Tweet from last night made clear, it’s folly to presume annouced attendance equals people in the seats.

Tyler Dellow has done some very good work this fall in examining the underlying financial state of that club, and one of the obvious things to me having simply watched several games is that not only is attendance down, but the expensive seats are unfilled in significant numbers.

As an experiment, I went to Ticketmaster this morning to check how many seats were stll unsold for the Stars’ home date versus the Sens next week. I selected that game in order to have a mid-week game against a team that doesn’t have a major travelling fan base, so that I could get at least some handle on how many lower-level seats weren’t sold as STHs or mini-packs. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The reason that I wanted to do that is that legitimately healthy teams sell those tickets before the puck drops for game one. That guaranteed income is what allows teams to function with some degree of certainty throughout the entire season, rather than simply hoping they sell tickets on a walkup basis. I counted the unsold seats in the 100 and 200 level, since that’s where the money is in terms of high priced ducats, and as of about 10 am CT, there were roughly 2800 tickets left in those areas. 

That’s a nice chunk of cash on the table. At an average ST price of around $3,000 for those seats, the Stars entered the year trying to sell at least $9M in quality tickets on spec, and I don’t doubt for a second that my rough attempt to account for what they have for inventory is likely a bit optimistic. Some of those seats will go via the walkup route for more desirable games, obviously, but the franchise is in a bit of a ditch as of today.

It should also be noted that many of those tickets are in areas with in-seat concession service, and people sitting in those types of places in other arenas are normally willing to spend a good buck on food and drink, so the loss of revenue from not having patrons in the chairs isn’t just confined to ticket revenue. I wish Gaglardi well, because he’s got a lot of work in front of him to rebuild the fanbase to the point where the Stars can spend in the manner he hopes.

That’s all for this week, and to our American readers, Happy Thanksgiving.


Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • T&A4Flames

    What I think is retarded is the All Star voting. People don’t even care if the player has even played more than 5 games and they are still voting for them. I thought the whole point was to vote for individuals having great seasons thus far and reward them for thier increased play. Crosby has only played a couple games and is at the top of the list. Don’t get me wrong I think Crosby is a great player but the voting should be based on current performance not whether its your favorite player.

    • justDOit

      Not sure what to think about that one. Whitney might never play a full season again, which is bad, and JBo plays every game, every season – which has also been bad. He might do well with a new team though, and I’m sure Renney/Krueger could bring back his game if given the chance.

      Was that a rumour from Eklund? If so, it’s almost guaranteed to never happen.

  • Romulus' Apotheosis

    Yakupov verses Hall in the battle of Alberta for the next decade should be fun. The only person in Cowtown who has not figured the Flamers are in rebuild mode is Feaster. I think Calgary tanks this season, trades a few pieces, but doesn’t do the traditional rebuild.

    • Talbot17

      except they cant just trade their scrap parts, lots of no trade clauses and bad contracts…

      they are going to float between 11th and last place for the next 3+ years easily

        • book¡e

          No, because they know they will ‘get out of there’ anyway – but to a team they like, whether it be sunny there or a stanley cup contender – they get to choose and Calgary has to takes whats they can gets for the player in return.

          Also, they cannot use the waiver or recall waiver as a means to lose any NMC players.

          NMCs and NTCs are very very costly and GMs have been too generous in giving them out. One very smart tradition of the Oilers is to say now way to most NMC and most NTCs.

      • NTCs don’t mean anything in reality; if a team doesn’t want a player, the player will waive the clause the vast majority of the time. Calgary will be fine, and they’ll find takers for some of their guys at the deadline if it comes to that.

  • Romulus' Apotheosis

    I’m not entirely convinced a team routinely dressing Theo Peckham won’t hit a slippery patch, in other words.

    understatement of the week!

    RE: Dallas… interesting to note Bettman chose Dallas celebrating a new owner over Crosby’s return the other night. His excitement at defying the laws of natural fan bases is off the chart.

  • book¡e

    This team needs to admit they suck. get rid of kipper and iggy, they are the problem. The Sutters are the best thing to happen to the flames since Lanny Mac.

  • T&A4Flames

    Uuuhhhhmmm, just heard that NYI placed Comeau on waivers. I know he hasn’t played great this year but seriously, if the Flames don’t try to pick him up they would have to be crazy. He is talented and a change of scenerey may be just what he needs. I don’t care if we are already over-loaded with wingers and forwards, this is a chance to get a good young talent; the fortuitous kind of move that can kick start a teams future fortunes… for free!

  • DK0

    I can see it now…

    Feaster: “Hey look guys! I found someone to take Iginla! Welcome your newest Calgary Flame, Dion Phaneuf! Playoffs here we come! more !’s!!”

  • T&A4Flames

    Uuuhhhhmmm, just heard that NYI placed Comeau on waivers. I know he hasn’t played great this year but seriously, if the Flames don’t try to pick him up they would have to be crazy. He is talented and a change of scenerey may be just what he needs. I don’t care if we are already over-loaded with wingers and forwards, this is a chance to get a good young talent; the fortuitous kind of move that can kick start a teams future fortunes… for free!

  • RexLibris

    I’d like to take this opportunity to nominate Brent Sutter alongside Jack Capuano, Scott Arniel and Claude Noel for the Jack Daniels Coach of the Year Award.

    I’m not convinced that the Flames go all the way and are able to draft Yakupov this year. I still think the players will turn this thing around after Christmas and the organization will suffer in the long run once again as they draft somewhere in the 6-10 range. Then, if Feaster isn’t “relocated” to another part of the organization in the summer, he’ll sign some free agents and the team will do it all over again, with another middling result and another middling draft position. Two years ago, by the end of November it looked like Carolina was going to draft 1st or 2nd overall, then they went on a tear and wound up drafting 7th. That Skinner kid worked out alright, but it wasn’t who they were hoping for (Seguin).

    I know the fans in Calgary want a rebuild because the prospects up to bat in this year and next are already being called spectacular, but the commitment to do it doesn’t appear in the ownership group on down.

  • O.C.

    Edmonton Oilers (11-8-2) – CBC Quarterly Review

    3 Stars: Nikolai Khabibulin, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Corey Potter

    Disappointment: Sam Gagner

    Same old: Face offs, offence from defence

    Sure, there was huge room for improvement, but the special team units have answered that challenge. There were expectations for Nugent-Hopkins, but certainly nothing of the order of a hat trick here, a five-assist game there. Perhaps Corey Potter won’t have staying power over a full season, but what a start for a guy who’s been cast off by two teams.

    Maybe it’s a lot to ask given the blue-line injury issues and the talent up front, but a couple more goals from the back end would have welcomed in the first quarter. Gagner seems destined to join Andrew Cogliano as someone who needs a change of scenery

    the only problem I see here is no mention of Eberle and Smyth.

  • book¡e

    Edmonton Oilers – TSN Quarterly Review

    With the influx of the young talent the Oilers have compiled through the past number of drafts, brighter days for the struggling franchise seemed inevitable. But while it looked like Edmonton was still a few years away, this year’s squad has looked like a team already prepared to challenge for a playoff spot, through the first quarter of the season.

    As expected, it is the young guns leading the way so far in Edmonton. Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Jordan Eberle, and Taylor Hall make up three of the top four scorers on the team with a combined 21 goals and 59 points.

    And re-acquired fan favourite Ryan Smyth is doing more than just providing veteran leadership for the Oilers’ young core of players. Smyth has contributed 11 goals and 22 points – tied for first in team scoring – through 21 games for the surprising Oilers.

    Another pleasant surprise in Edmonton has been the play of Nikolai Khabibulin. The Russian veteran entered the year expecting to split time with Devan Dubnyk, but has since been given the majority of starts, posting a .936 save percentage and two shutouts.

    • Gee. The winner of every award is in the East except for Shea Weber and the Calder is NOT going to the youngest eligible player who happens to be pacing out for a better year than any rookie post lock-out since Ovie, Malkin, and Crosby.

      Well done, Scott Cullen. Well done.

      I’m surprised he didnt choose the Panthers as the eventual winners of the Western Conference Championship.

  • As suggested by Kent in the comments over at M&G, I have registered my vote for Stajan on the All-Star ballot. Let’s get him on the team, and then we can see where he gets selected in the team draft. (um… last)

  • justDOit

    While it may be more difficult than Cartman abstaining from ripping on Kyle’s religion, I think it’s bad karma to rip on the Flambes for their troubles.

    Oh wait – Feaster ripped the Oilers in the media, didn’t he… carry on, then!

    Even if they tank the rest of the season and get a high draft pick, I’m sure they’ll squander it on the next Rico Fata!

  • geoilersgist

    Rumour from radio. They even said its fairly implausible. Anything going to Cow Country must have major contract going back, cause JBO is a 3 mil player making 6 plus. I think JBO will go somewhere, cause I think in the right situation (say the other evil red team, Detroit) he can be a 40 point guy again.

    • RexLibris

      I can’t wait to hear the press conference with Feaster at the end of the year if the Oilers finished ahead of the Flames.

      Hopefully the Calgary will be a little harder on Feaster than the U.S. media was on George W: “So W, about those Iraqi weapons of mass destruction…”

  • everton fc

    Back to Comeau… What’s his cap hit? Might be worth a punt.

    Canes trying to move Kaberle for a forward. Would they take Stajan and Sarich?! Or Stajan and Babchuk??!! (Just dreaming…)

  • justDOit

    Is this writer from Toronto? Because this article looks ridiculously Toronto biased. Toronto has lots of injuries and thats the only reason they’re not playing well. Meanwhile, no mention that the Oilers have way more injuries than the Sappers. Nice homework.

  • 24% body fat

    Its kind of funny. A while back on here I had a discussion with VINTAGE FLAME comparing the situation of the 07 oilers to the flamers of today. He was very upset and said they were no where near the same. He aske me how I could think the flames were going to be terrible for the next five years, and I said because we went through the same thing.

    My arguments were – 1 really good player each (hemsky and iginla), only 1 descent prospect (gagner and backlund which i will now change to baertchi), lost there best defensemen (pronger and regher). And a bunch of below average top six fill ins (Smythe, horcoff, Stoll and for the flames, Jokinen, Glencross, and Bourque I believe). BTW smitty is not below average.

    Needless to say he was discusted by my comparison. Hemsky wasnt in the same league as iginla, and he would take his overpaid underperforming never accomplished anything over the oilers fill ins lead by smythe.

    So for a rebutal I did some depth research, all the oilers player totals from 07 added up to a significantly higher number points than the flames and with fewer games player. And guess what I even conceeded the Iginla-Hemsky argument to him. So the situation added up was actually worse for the flames. Their players are untradeable, worse, and paid more.

    Well here we are and a quarter of the games are finished. And he was right. They arent the same situation. The flames are a much worse team on pace for 70 points to the oilers 88 in 07. Smythe is tearing the league apart. Hemsky is still much younger than Iginla and on a much higher scoring pace than Iginla. Horcoff the lowest scoring of my so called fill ins is outscoring all of the flames fill ins and also Mr. Magnificent Jerome Iginla.

    Now what are the flames to do. Right now the hopes of the furture of their franchise are on the shoulders of a mid first round pick from switzerland, and the so called number one center has yet to get a point let alone beat the 40pt mark. Iginla and Kiper are dropping their trade value so bad no one will give anything up for them, and most of the other contracts are unmovable. So now factor in Calgarys late season heroics and we have a tenth place team because Feaster wont use the word rebuild. Hey I dont blame him, he was left with a bad mess. But rebuild seems to be a word he should be using more than the ones he chose to say in regards to the standings and their position relative to their rival.

    I guess VINTAGE FLAME means through on your 04 Iginla Jersey and watch the cup run one more time. I miss Hakan Loob.

    • RexLibris

      I’ll agree with what you’ve said about your analysis of the team, they don’t look good on paper and they are currently underperforming even to those standards. However,…

      Remember how upset we were as Oiler fans at the start of ’07 after the Cup run when The Hockey News predicted a 12th place finish in the West for us? We were all convinced that Horcoff, Hemsky, Smyth, Stoll, Greene, Torres, Roloson, Smith, Staios, Pisani and company were going to be another playoff team. We looked at everybody’s performance the year before as a mark of expected averages (rather than as likely career-highs) and that the team would remain balanced and effective. It was only the objective observer and the outsider who looked at Smith and Staios as a top defense pairing and said this wasn’t going to work. Then came the gut-wrenching feeling of watching your team play such absolutely terrible hockey that it almost became a comedy of errors.

      I imagine Flames fans are feeling the same way right now. To this point the team has underwhelmed even by most outsider’s expectations. Just about every prediction I read before the season had the Flames as high as 7th and as low as 11th in the West. The bloggers and fans on this site were expressing guarded optimism about the season, wondering if the 2nd-half Flames were the real team or the 1st half Flames. Right now they are worse than anyone thought they were going to be (Of course, teams like Dallas, Columbus, Edmonton, and Minnesota are making everyone’s predictions look bad right now). If the Flames are worse right now than the Oilers were at this point in the ’06-’07 season then the fans have every right to be freaking out. As you said, the Oilers at least had a half-dozen injuries to use as an excuse. This off-season will be a crossroads for the franchise and if Feaster and Ken King stay true to their words (refusal to rebuild), then I suspect this is only the beginning of a long and painful chapter in the team’s history.

      VF has already come on and said he needs to get ready to eat some crow, in fact I believe he said something about eating a paragraph he had earlier written. But I’m going to wait until the final game of the year before I start calling him out on any pre-season claims.

      That being said, as an Oiler fan, I’m really looking forward to Dec 3rd and hoping that they can absolutely hammer the Flames. But I know that Flames fans would hope the same for their team.

  • RexLibris

    I’m not going to say to any Oiler fan that they shouldn’t be gleefully rubbing their hands at the current situation, after having to listen to Flames fans wax poetic about the Oilers, Edmonton, the fans, the ownership, the management, and so on for the last number of years. God knows I’m getting a good dose of shadenfreude from watching the hand-wringing and hair-pulling of Flames fans, but I also don’t want the fans of my beloved Oilers to get the reputation that Canucks fans have.

    In spite of what Brian Burke and Dean Lombardi would claim, the Oilers organization has always had a reputation for class and sportsmanship and I hope that if and when our team gets to another Stanley Cup final our team and city will have behaved in a way that has fans from across Canada cheering for us.