"Friend of the Nation Network – and two time Angler Cup Champion – Brian Sutherby has shared his thoughts about the Trade Deadline for the second time in less than a week. In this installment he takes a look at the difficulties of making a big move at the deadline and the impact new arrivals have on a dressing room this late in the season. He also calls a winner for this year’s deadline day. – Wanye

With a relatively uneventful trade deadline having passed, many folks are busy debating the Winners and Losers of the deadline. I thought I’d offer my two bits on the matter too.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Many teams had different needs going into the big day and judging the team that played their cards right is always fun. Rather than the big blockbuster deals many had anticipated and hoped for, we saw most teams this season adding depth or in most cases doing nothing at all.

No one really made any moves that blew the roof off their team and unlike recent years, there was little frenzy for the disappointed fans and media alike to enjoy.

Now we are all left to ask ourselves and each other – how did our particular team do and did anyone hand themselves the Cup?


Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Fans of teams already loaded with talent often figure that adding a big star like Rick Nash can push them over the top and take them to a championship. But what we have seen this year was contending GMs standing pat for the most part, not wanting to mess with what are in most cases already very good lineups.

Acquiring a rental player or making a giant move late in the season always comes with risk. The team is sacrificing the future in favour of the right now and the chance to go deep in the playoffs is by no means assured. For that to happen a lot of things have to go right and pulling off deadline moves is only one piece of a much larger puzzle.

There are a lot of factors in play with a move this late in the season and it can be a lot for any player or team to adjust to with just over a month before playoffs. It’s a tough decision and a big deal can have immediate impact on your team – either positively or negatively. Once the deal is done there is no turning back and many a team has done deals they would later rather have back.

This level of risk combined with steep asking prices is the reason – in my opinion – that most GMs preferred to not tinker very much and why there were so few deals this year.


The hope for many GMs and fans alike is that a big move on Deadline Day – eithe rental type trades or landing a player for the long run –  can improve the team dramatically in a short span of time. This could mean putting a team over the top and becoming favourites to win the Cup, jumping up the conference standings or making that all important push into a playoff spot.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

But just because a deal looks fabulous on paper doesn’t always translate to reality. There are a great many intangibles that come with making a move this late in the season and the added pressure of having to adjust to a big shakeup in the line up with the season on the line is often reason enough that teams wait to make big moves in the offseason.

So there’s no need to panic if your team sat tight through the deadline. A great many moons have to align to make that magical run, not just a deadline deal.


A secondary scorer, a role player, or depth guy can certainly be all that is needed in many cases to take a team to the next level. Yet often in the days after the deadline, many people are quick to label teams that were the most active in acquiring multiple players or that landed a star player, the “winners”.

Though it has happened in the past, making the most deals or landing the biggest name on Trade Deadline day doesn’t always translate into success during the remainder of the season. What looked like a great move on paper at the deadline may not look so good in a month if you consider everything that needs to happen in such a short amount of time.

As I talked about before a player’s life goes upside down if they are dealt mid season. There are new team mates to work with, new team systems to learn, new Coaches to adjust to, new roles to take on and that ever elusive ‘chemistry’ that needs to be found in a short span of time.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

All of these factors aren’t apparent in evaluating a paper transaction and often times you can’t predict how these factors will affect a trade until you pull the trigger and see what happens. In a month’s time, once the moves have had a chance to set in, we will be in a much better position to evaluate the trade deadline winners and losers.


However, saying that it will take a month to judge the winner of the trade deadline isn’t any fun. And it certainly won’t appease my self appointed editor Wanye who wants “ANSWERS NOW!”

With that in mind, I’d have to say that I liked several teams’ moves in the weeks leading up to the Trade Deadline and on the big day itself. I liked what Nashville and Vancouver did and their moves may get them to where they want to be. Both teams I believe improved themselves for a deep run.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

But my opinion come playoff time is the Boston Bruins are still the team to beat if they can stay healthy and have enough gas.

They already have the experience, size, and skill. The additions of depth defenseman like Greg Zanon, Mike Mottau and a forward like Brian Rolston, who can play up and down the lineup, while adding a veteran presence like Recchi did last year, is great this time of year. These three won’t be asked to carry the load by any means, but they can fill holes when needed.

In the end I think it’s pretty clear who most teams think they have to go through to get to Lords Stanley. Teams adding Hal Gill 6’7” 241 pounds, Paul Gaustad 6’5” 212 pounds, Zack Kassian 6’4 215 pounds, not to mention the Eastern Conference leading New York Rangers picking up John Scott 6’8 270 pounds.

The winner of the Trade Deadline this year: the Big Bad B’s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Eulers

    The B’s just won their FIST cup in nearly 30 years. Personally, I’m hoping Tim ‘The Tool’ Thomas and the boys spread the wealth around a bit and someone else takes home the hardware this year!

    • Brian Sutherby

      You may be right. It’s never easy to repeat, but I still think in a 7 game series they are going to be a lot for any team to handle. Who’s your pick?

  • Clyde Frog

    For the good of Hockey in the US, I vote New York.

    Remember when the NHL was thought to be on a bigger rise than the NBA? To the point FOX was highlighting the puck to lessen America’s confusion at tracking the play! People were paying money to create new hockey teams throughout the United States, heck they were moving teams out of Canada because support was so strong!

    That was the last time New York won the cup and was competitive…

    Could be coincidence, but why risk it? Just cheer for the Rangers and bring back the good old days… I’m sure thats all it will take.

  • The Hall Way

    Did Wayne mature after his Asia trip or what? There wasn’t a single Bieber reference, nothing about sending hair to Eberle, or any **** notations. What the heck happened?

    ** Also: i like the B’s chances this year, and i think Edmonton made a good move. Schultz seems to be a stronger shutdown guy which we need badly.

  • Chaz

    Hey Wanye,

    Not sure if you read the Isaac Asimov quiz in the journal, but yesterday’s edition was about the first person to do a certain thing. And it was revealed that the first woman to swim across the English Channel was Gertrude Eberle.

    As a tribute to his great aunt Gertrude, I propose that Jordon does a Toe-Drag / Dangle / Backhand Roof move across the Channel this summer….after having won the MVP and leading Canada to Gold at the World Championships that is.

    That is all.

  • Reg Dunlop

    The big winners this year? I don’t know, maybe Nashville. The big losers? Definitely the Flames. With their best players on the wrong side of 30, their gumper with a lot of miles on him, hard miles, this years post season a fading dream, a GM promising a major shake-up and then recanting and doing nothing…

    This was the last best chance for the phlegms to get a decent return on fading assets. Next year at this time a 36 year old Kipper or Iggy coming from a 25th place Calgary team won’t be as in demand. Maybe they should hold onto them to retirement like the Isles did in the ’80s,leading to 2 decades of toilet dwelling.

    Regarding the Oil’s move, I think this type of shoring up should have been done months earlier. Stability and calm defence late in close games could have added maybe 10 points to our total. Fewer panic moments in the last minutes with a lead, running around chasing the Canucks while they cycle in our end for minutes ay a time.

  • Spydyr

    Pancake Penner’s wife had enough of cooking pancakes she is out the door.

    On a related note donair shops in L.A. report a 50% increase in sales as he tries to drown his sorrows in donair sauce.

    • book¡e

      Guys tend to lose weight and get in shape again once the wife leaves. They also have more time to do things like play hockey and hang out at the rink.

      Perhaps Penner will get his Mojo back now – might be worth an offseason signing on the cheap.

    • Clyde Frog

      /Social Responsibility On

      There are some places not to kick a guy when he is down, affairs of the heart are one of them.

      I think pancakes and donairs are funny, but honestly why target him when he is going through something truly terrible.

      /Social Responsibility Off

      It wasn’t even that funny..

  • Talbot17

    I dont see any team out West beating the Canucks, unless NSH surprises come playoff time (doubtful) or Chicago gets going. Detroit just seems like a team that the first 3 games of a series will average 40+ shots on goal a game and still lose 3-2 to a team like the Canucks.

    Having said that, Really want Boston or NYR to get to the cup and prevent the Canucks from winning this year

  • Eulers

    @Brian Sutherby

    I’ll go with dark horses Ottawa or NJ from the East and cheer for the only Canadian team that’s going to make it from the West even if they are the Canucks!