Guessing the Leafs’ opening night lineup and where it goes from there

In less than five weeks the Leafs will fly out to the best part of the world to get their training camp started in St. John’s, a beautiful city in Newfoundland. Leading up to that, we can expect the release of a pretty inflated list of invites who’ll be making the journey and trying to make the team. Some new players will “look good” and surprise us a bit, other established guys might look sluggish and there’ll be calls about whether they’re in trouble of being bumped, and so on. Coaches will talk about how some of the minor league b’ys are gunning for spots and trying to take jobs. We all know how it goes.

But in the end, just like most years, there really isn’t an open spot on this roster. There isn’t much there for the taking, and we can probably already put together the final lineup with a very high degree of accuracy.

But there are really two “final rosters” aren’t there? With the Leafs enduring significant injuries to Zach Hyman and Travis Dermott, as well as having Mitch Marner in a potential holdout situation, it’s smarter to speculate on how the lineup looks on opening night October 2nd, and then what it will eventually settle into, more or less, when everyone’s ready to go (assuming there aren’t additional injuries, of course).

There’s nothing too scientific about this, I’ve just watched enough training camps and gotten a bit of a handle on how things shake out, and sometimes where the early situational hype comes into play.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Opening night against the Senators



There are some surprises here but the explanations should be relatively straight-forward. For one, Marner isn’t included, and the simple reason is that I half-expect him to miss a game or two in this contract stalemate situation, though it definitely won’t go to the wire like things did with Nylander. In the meantime Kapanen slots in on that line and Kerfoot starts out as a wing since that’s probably where he’s best, and the Leafs will want to bolster that line a little with Hyman and Marner missing. Spezza can essentially play anywhere in the bottom six, Moore is a full-timer, and Mikheyev is definitely going to be a Babcock favourite early who gets a proper look. The fourth line is the fourth line.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The top four in the defence seems somewhat interchangeable to start, or until Dermott comes back and tries to force someone out if he can move to the other side, which is still very much up in the air. I think even though Harpur has looked brutal with the Sens, the Leafs will try him out in real games to see what they have, and Liljegren gets a few games to start in a sheltered role because he’s probably close to capable, and it would be a nice little shot in the arm for his confidence. He doesn’t stick though. I realize Sandin is the better prospect and perhaps even more ready, but his timeline is simply further out as far as the “see what we have in him at the NHL level” thinking goes.

Which brings us to when the dust settles.

The real roster with everyone in it

I titled this picture “eventually” when I saved it, and that’s what it is: The Leafs’ lineup, eventually.

The Leafs made a play for Schmaltz as a depth right-hander and gave up a decent fringe player to get him in Borgman, which signals to me they see some talent there in the former first-rounder. Call it an appeal to authority but I think he gets there and proves them right, settling into the bottom pairing alongside Dermott. The top four is the top four until Dermott forces Ceci out, and perhaps that goes down, but I’m banking on Ceci bouncing back and being serviceable.

Up front the top six is hard to argue against. Line three is one that can keep opponents on their heels and drive people mad with speed. There could be a bit of movement in the bottom six, but I think the players listed here are all NHLers, which goes back to the point about nothing being open for anyone new in camp (i.e. Bracco), unless (or perhaps until) things get shaken up by injuries.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Again, this isn’t a ranking based on who I think is best at each position or whatnot. It’s simply a gut-feel thing about how I believe the roster will play out given training camps of the past, some chemistry observations, and tendencies of the front office and coaching staff. Disagree? Let me hear it.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Tanner Hopwo-Swift

    Looks good! But I’ve noticed that not to many people including Babcock have thought about having Willy and Kappy on the same line. When they played together in the Ahl they had great chemistry and are terrific friends not saying that will make the transition from the ahl but I’m just thinking with Willys control and Kappys speed and throw Auston in there that could be a line that could dominate teams. I like Mango and think he should be top six for sure but why not try out Kappy and Willy at least for a couple preseason games or something.

  • Matmarwill

    I don’t think that kerfoot will be played anywhere but 3c unless there are very serious injury problems. He needs to get established as a center to be the most useful for the leafs. So in your opening night lineup, spezza sinks to 4c:

    Johnsson + Matthews + nylander
    Moore + Tavares + bracco
    Mikheyev + kerfoot + kappy
    Aberg + spezza + shore.

    I can see Dermott pushing ceci to 3rhd paired with Gravel/harpur/Sandin. I would expect in that scenario the ceci is eventually traded and Liljegren is brought up.

    If Marner returns, bracco goes back to the Marlies. When Hyman returns Mikheyev moves to the fourth line and aberg hits the press box.

  • magesticRAGE

    I agree, the top six is pretty much set. Matthews will have his elite setup man on his wing for the season. Hyman’s place is in cement as long as Babcock has breathe, and Tavares will have his “Robin” to complete the duo.
    I love Moore’s game, it’s hard not to. If I know Babcock, he will default to the vet in Mikheyev on Kerfoot’s wing, Kapanen in the right. Moore is essentially the teams ultra utility guy, where you can plug him in virtually anywhere and in any situation. He will be on the 4th line, but he will get his minutes. Spezza will center the 4th, might even platoon with Gauthier, and Petan will switch out Aberg.

    Dermott will eventually move to Rielly’s right, he has that experience before on his off-side against top competition. Ceci is just an expensive place holder. Marincin will play with him until they can find a new home, and then Schmaltz takes over. It’s a shame really, Holl has the better numbers, in both the minors and NHL. That’s Babcock though…