The top 10 Maple Leafs stories of 2013

Time to ring in the New Year. Early tomorrow morning we’ll have a post previewing the Winter Classic. If you have an outdoor hockey memory you’d like to share with us, please email at camcharron(at) After the Winter Classic game, which will be Game 42 on the season, the rest of the week will be devoted to looking at Toronto’s first half of the season. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

For now, though, here are the big stories that The Leafs Nation wrote on in 2013, including the posts that attracted the most interest. It was a wild 2013, that began with a management shakeup, included a playoff appearance, a series of controversial offseason decisions, and the Leafs also became the latest team to buck statistical trends. Thank you all for reading in 2013. We wouldn’t do this if not for you.


#10 – Nazem Kadri’s bitter contract dispute

The biggest Ontario-born Maple Leaf since Dougie thought he had some leverage after a 44-points-in-48-games season, but Dave Nonis stuck to his guns and signed Nazem Kadri through training camp.

The best part of all this? Sportsnet reporter and Friend Of The Nation David Alter reported that Kadri wanted a $6-million deal, and The Wizard of Naz shot that down quite aggressively on Twitter.

TSN’s Bob McKenzie reported a similar number, and Nazem Kadri responded with a Tweet of the Year candidate:

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

#9 – Leafs management say silly things in the offseason 

Maple Leafs Hot Stove runs a print publication every year, but the quick turnaround and difficulty finding a publisher meant they had to run all of their content online, including interviews with Leafs staff that raised some eyebrows. 

First was Greg Cronin suggesting the Leafs weren’t a team that got significantly out-possessed in 2013 (and I have to wonder if he still believes that after watching the first half of this year) but then there was Dave Poulin making one of his many silly claims, suggesting that you can judge Tyler Bozak on the fact that he plays so well with Phil Kessel.

Again… and it bears repeating, that is just objectively, fantastically wrong and continues to be wrong.

#8 – Leafs fan gets sucker punched in Boston

I’ll let Steve describe this:

After the Leafs’ Game 2 victory over the Boston Bruins, a video began to make the rounds of a Leafs fan lying unconscious in the TD Garden. Witnesses said he had been assaulted by an angry Bruins fan (who ran off and has not been found), and taken to hospital. The video now has well over 45,000 views.

As more information came out, the victim’s identity became public. His name is Kyle Hay, and it turns out that he is a friend of a friend of mine, Bryan Barton. Bryan happened to be there with him, as well. I got in contact with both of them late Sunday night. Many people have been asking about the exact details of the incident, so here’s what they had to say.

Kyle was able to share his story with The Leafs Nation, and the Maple Leafs gave him tickets to Game 4:

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

#7 – Dallas Eakins ditches Toronto

The quotable, fiery Dallas Eakins left the Maple Leafs’ minor league organization in the summer for Edmonton. He’s been a bit of a controversial hire, considering the Oilers disappointing record. Jeffler, who has been covering the Marlies for a while, wrote a detailed post on what the Oilers could expect from Eakins and so far, Edmonton media have learned he can be prickly to deal with if asked dumb questions.

So far my favourite answer to a question in Edmonton. “Talk about David Perron’s hands.” “Well… he has a left one and a right one.”

#6 – The Dion Phaneuf debate

The Maple Leafs re-signed their Captain to a seven-year deal, officially announced New Year’s Eve. Over the last week of December, we’ve had some conflicting views on this website about whether it’s a risky contract or not, but nobody can deny that Phaneuf plays some of the toughest minutes in the NHL.

#5 – Paul Ranger returns to the NHL

We don’t know why Paul Ranger left the NHL when he did, but when he came back, he was a cheap, low-risk option that could conceivably give the Leafs another body in the top four. Unfortunately, that hasn’t materialized, but it’s not like the Leafs erred in bringing him back and seeing what he could do after a year in the minors.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

#4 – The Phil Kessel contract extension

Was the best part of Phil Kessel’s contract the part where Kessel basically stuck it to every critic that questioned his big game ability for years before he dragged the Maple Leafs to the playoffs a year ago? Phil Kessel was rewarded for a long-term, high money deal just before the start of the season, but probably less than he would have earned on the open market. A bit risky due to its length, but nobody can deny Kessel is elite at what he does. He’s on pace for his best goal-scoring season, is taking close to 4 shots a game, and still has three years left of his peak.

Also, was 2013 the year that hockey started to come around on the original Kessel trade? After Tyler Seguin went to Dallas, it’s not looking like such a steal any more.

#3 – Tyler Bozak vs. Mikhail Grabovski

This debate kept us blog writers warm and fed through the summer. Editorially, everybody on this site was pretty well dead set against the Bozak extension. My post on why Tyler Bozak should have played his last game as a Leaf was one of our most-read posts of the year, as was Jeffler’s discussion post about “Nozak”.

And for those of you who suggest that we don’t have the guts to face the players we criticize, Jeffler ran into Bozie and introduced himself in Yorkdale at a signing event.

All told, here are the stories we wrote on Bozak or Grabovski that were big during the summer:

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

#2 – It Was Four One And Then They Lost

The best was how Sean McIndoe classified Those Games: “They’re the ones where the sports gods skip past winning and losing and move straight to abject cruelty.” There were a variety of different reactions. Our postgame thread comments were just full of shockEven Hat Guy had nothing to say in Steve’s LFR video.

The craziest reaction is Jeffler’s optimistic post about the pieces that the Leafs put together. From Game 2 against the Bruins and on, the Maple Leafs really looked like a hockey team. They were skating with the Bruins, weren’t getting out-possessed and a few injuries meant they were icing their best roster. I think for some of us, the frustration in the offseason has more to do with the fact we wouldn’t get to see that playoffs Leafs team for a full year.

#1 – Brian Burke fired and replaced by Dave Nonis

Brian Burke’s zinger-laden press conference was the end of his long, yet unsuccessful, tenure as captain of the Good Ship Leaf. Burke’s virtues were that he didn’t leave the team any long, problem contracts.

Dave Nonis, however, wasted no time in turning over the roster. He signed David Clarkson, acquired David Bolland, and picked up Jonathan Bernier to give the Leafs a 1A goalie. The Burke firing was surprising at the time, and caught a lot of us off guard right before the season was due to start.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • STAN

    I thought the story of this year was the Clarkson signing, based on ‘sources’ (Clarkson’s camp) who said Clarkson had a similar offer from Edmonton.

    The same stories kept referring to Clarkson’s lifelong love of all things Leafs and that this was his goal all along, to play for the Maple Leafs.

    Even basic due diligence by Nonis & Co. would have known this and stuck with Burke’s rule of five seasons MAX. My guess is Clarkson would have still chosen five seasons with his ‘dream team’ than seven seasons in Edmonton.

    In news directly related to the Clarkson signing is that a newly-signed GM, or any GM, would let MacArthur walk FOR NOTHING, pay Grabovski $15M to play for the Capitals and then grossly overspend for a third line checker like Clarkson.

    So for me, Mr. Leiweke and the big shots at MLSE must be looking at MacArthur’s 29 points, 12 goals and PLUS 13 along with Grabbo’s 30 points, 11 goals and PLUS 5 and Clarkson’s 8 points, 3 goals and MUNUS 2… and feel just great about their general manager’s judgement.

  • STAN

    Another quick suggestion: appoint Masai Ujiri Leafs President and GM. He’s not afraid to move a overpaid, under performers (Bargnani, Gay) and actually get great returns.