Photo Credit: Tom Szczerbowski-USA TODAY Sports

Off-season fun with OwnThePuck’s Lineup Creator

When it comes to quickly comparing players in the NHL, there’s probably no better resource than Dominic Galamini’s OwnThePuck – a site containing relatively easy-to-use tools to “provide a cursory look at the performance of skaters using modern statistics”, as its founder puts it. Regular readers of this site might notice OTP’s HERO charts in a lot of our work when we want to quickly get a rundown of a player’s role and pace on both sides of the puck.

As of yesterday, OwnThePuck includes a “Lineup Creator” that Galamini has been developing recently. It’s a spreadsheet tool that allows you to plug players into an existing lineup and optimize a number of even-strength metrics, along with an overall points projection over an 82-game season.

You can see how something like this would make viewing offseason transactions through a critical lens quite simple, but what’s stopping us from plugging in some potential moves right now? Tinkering with the Leafs’ roster and inserting some names that have popped up trade rumours and free agency is always a good time, so let’s give it a whirl.

First off, this is how the existing Leafs lineup looks in OTP’s new gadget (Soshnikov is in for Kapanen in this example because there is cut-off of 400-minutes-played):

That’s a middle-of-the-pack lineup, and the expected points through 82 games reflects that at 96.3. The model assumes average goaltending and perfect health – both of which the Leafs more-or-less maintained this past season. Considering the real-life Leafs landed at 95 points, that’s a nice way to pass the sniff test.

Now let’s see how we can elevate this group into a potential division-winner.

First off, I’m going to knock Hyman off that top line because, while he’s a fine play-driver, the poor guy has such a difficult time contributing to the score sheet. Let’s put in another player who can push the puck in the right direction, but has a little more finish. Justin Williams is a free agent, and might not command an other-worldly salary, so I’m shooting my shot and adding him to try and create a contender. Hyman moves to a better fit on the fourth line.

Next, we’re bringing Jumbo Joe home. Bozak is out (maybe as part of a trade for defensive help), and Thornton distributes between two elite offensive wingers in JVR and Marner.

Lastly, we’re doing some work on the blue line. The Zaitsev and Rielly pairing stays intact, while Gardiner gets a big boost in the addition of Josh Manson, who most believe can shake loose from the Ducks as a result of the Vegas draft. Carrick is lost to the Knights in that draft, so we fill out the bottom pairing by bringing in Brendan Smith as a free agent, and adding a Marlies player or other cheap depth.

How’s this going to look?


It’s unsurprising that adding a bunch of strong puck-possession players (including a Hall of Fame center) to an already talented group brings the team up a few steps. The projected 105 points would likely be enough to contend for the Atlantic division, as Montreal just wrapped it up with 103 this past season. Adding players like Manson and Smith to the back-end does a lot to bring down that Corsi Against column, which is obviously what we’d expect if the Leafs were successful in bringing in that kind of help this summer.

Of course, this is really just a fun exercise for the armchair general manager in all of us. Toronto hasn’t done particularly well in free agency in the last number of years, and the market for a defenceman like Manson (or Brodin, Dumba, Tanev, and so on) will be absurdly competitive in the coming months. So this dream team of mine is exactly that. We don’t know what the going rate will be on all these players, either in terms of dollars in free agency, or trade cost.

But this a great way to visualize how upgrades to the roster can fit in, and should be a great tool to utilize when the Leafs actually do something this offseason. Maybe they are successful in getting one of those players mentioned, or someone else comparable.

The plug-and-play nature of this model makes it easy to use and the outputs digestible for anyone, which is basically the hallmark of Galamini’s work to date. If you want to give it a spin, go to OwnThePuck.com and grab the Excel file, then get to work.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Harte of a Lion

    I’d like to see Patrick Marleau in Justin Williams spot. Williams moves to JVR’s spot because that’s the key player going to the Ducks 50% retained salary for Manson. There is a kid I’ve been reading about in the Swiss league that looks like he could be a future NHL player. Yannick Rathgeb, a 21-year old right defenseman playing for HC Fribourg-Gottéron of the NLA.. I’ve been saying for a few weeks that they also need to sign Darren Raddysh. He played with both Brown and Dermott in Erie, is a local boy and if he can take his skating up a notch (Another Underhill project) I believe he slots in easily as a 2nd pairing RHD. His brother was drafted by Tampa so he may want the chance to play with his brother but it’s worth perusing, are you listening Lou?

  • Kevin

    Not sure about Joe Thornton, he’ll be coming off of major knee surgery and may not be able to keep up. He’ll probably want a 2 year deal and this will be an over 35 deal with the money staying on the cap. Marleau might be a better bet despite being the same age and could be a potential short term replacement for JVR (if he is traded). Justin Williams is interesting and might be a good fit especially if Komarov leaves.

    • magesticRAGE

      I bet Leivo will put up more points than if Marleau was brought over, slightly anyway. I wish prospects has enough stats to plug in, would love to see Grundstrom take over Hyman’s spot.

  • Gary Empey

    I am surprised so many Leaf fans feel we should bring in players that will soon be hitting their forties and move out 27 year old guys like JVR. Common sense should tell you, for the top nine, Leaf management is looking for young, fast, players with character. Marleau, Williams, and Thornton have all had their day in the sun. It is at the trade deadline when those sort of older, rental type, players are considered, depending on where we are in the standings. It seems like a lot of people feel we are just one player away from the Stanley Cup finals. In fact last year we were one point away from missing the playoffs.

    • millzy09

      I understand your thought process but it’s the 27 yo that will want 5+ years and is already starting to show signs of slowing down vs an older guy that can still play that you can likely get on a very short deal. Plus you need to keep cycling out things of value for young roster players, prospects and picks otherwise the reservoir dries up and you only sustain a few years. Chicago model has kept them relevant, LA is fading away.

    • m@

      The thinking is that JVR can get you a good/great asset before losing him for nothing July 2018. I’d like to keep JVR, but can’t see that happening with big pay days coming to Matthews, Nylander and Marner in the next couple of years. Williams cost nothing but salary, and you can probably get him on a reasonable contract for 2-3 years.

      I really think he’s the perfect veteran FA for the Leafs.. if they choose to go in that direction.

      • Gary Empey

        Well you and Millzy09 are likely wrong as far as the Shanaplan goes. Babcock and Lou are both at the worlds at this moment scouting and have already announced they will be signing 24 years old guys to add the depth that we lack. JVR is under contract for next year. He scored 29 goals and added 33 assists. A sixty point player. If one decides you either don’t want him or can’t afford him then the best time to move him would be the trade deadline, when there will be true Stanley Cup contenders that will pay an arm and a leg for a player of this calibre. Just my opinion. I do understand the three players mentioned have had outstanding NHL careers and likely could go one more year at least. There is never any 100% right or wrong, when speculating on the best way to improve the team.