The Toronto Maple Leafs fell short in an eighth consecutive winner-take-all game with a 6-1 drumming at the hands of the Florida Panthers.
After working hard to secure <a href="https://theleafsnation.com/news/trying-find-calmess-madness-toronto-maple-leafs-core-four-era" target="_blank" rel="noopener">a shot at redemption</a> on home ice following a 6-1 blowout loss in Game 5, the Leafs instead decided to lay an even bigger egg than they did four nights prior. All the work done in the regular season to secure home ice and progress towards implementing a new playing style vanished as quickly as the Panthers were able to build on their lead, and they did not relinquish.
It was a sight that has become all-too familiar to Leafs fans since the start of the Core Four era: a Game 7 loss where the stars fail to produce, the goalie lets them down, too many defensive blunders, and a lack of authority and desperation. As a result of this latest heartbreak, the fans inside Scotiabank Arena made their point that they are exhausted with having to relieve the same song and dance by raining out boos and tossing debres on the ice such as jerseys.
To know that those scenes came less than two hours after the building was buzzing with an electric atmosphere before puck drop that is not often seen even in the playoffs makes the performance all the more maddening. From the jump, the Leafs were playing as nervously as they have ever been, and it snowballed into the stretch in the second period where things unravelled. There were certainly moments where it looked like the team could break through and change the trajectory of the game, but they once again did not do enough to make Sergei Bobrovsky&#8217;s job difficult or to plant any seed of doubt in their opponent. If anything, the Panthers were playing more like the team that was trailing 6-1 instead of the actual one.
When things began to spiral, everyone on the ice lost their composure and <a href="https://theleafsnation.com/news/mitch-marner-instructs-toronto-maple-leafs-wake-up-trailing-game-7-florida-panthers" target="_blank" rel="noopener">resorted to yelling at each other</a>. In the immediate aftermath of the game, captain Auston Matthews said there were <a href="https://theleafsnation.com/news/auston-matthews-toronto-maple-leafs-too-many-passengers-game-7" target="_blank" rel="noopener">&#8216;too many passengers&#8217;.</a> In reflecting on why the Leafs played so horrendously for two straight home games, head coach Craig Berube was at a loss for words when trying to describe why it happened.
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-width="550" data-dnt="true">
Craig Berube was heated during the second period 
📽️: Sportsnet <a href="https://t.co/6VlCTws076">pic.twitter.com/6VlCTws076</a>
&mdash; TheLeafsNation (@TLNdc) <a href="https://twitter.com/TLNdc/status/1924276310454505513?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">May 19, 2025</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
This is a core that is running out of answers and running out of time to get things right. This version of the Leafs with Matthews, Mitch Marner, William Nylander, and John Tavares is all but over, with the makeup of the roster expected to look quite different when the 2025-26 season commences in roughly five months from now. Whether that be through trades, free agent signings, or the emergence of prospects such as Easton Cowan, the offseason will likely bring forth significant changes to a team that once again fell short of hockey glory.
It could also spell the end of Brendan Shanahan&#8217;s tenure, with his longstanding bet that the nucleus will one day break through in the postseason yet again blowing up in his face. Apart from the Core Four and Morgan Rielly, the Leafs&#8217; president has been the one constant presence throughout this nearly decade-long nightmare in the postseason. There is no denying that he has done well in building a team that has been successful in the regular season as evidenced by them boasting the longest active playoff streak at nine consecutive appearances. But fans don&#8217;t care for those stats or the fact that the team won a division title: they want to see meaningful progress in the postseason and a team that at least gives it their all no matter the result.
This is why the Leafs teams of the 1990s and 2000s continued to be revered despite them also falling short in the playoffs, whereas this modern era is being looked at with disdain and disgust. Those teams of old never went down without a fight and gave the fanbase something to be proud of in spite of the loss, while the current iterations withered under the pressure and played timidly to allow their opponent a chance at dictating the pace.
It&#8217;s no wonder that things unravelled into a circus during the third period of Game 7 because Leafs fans are beyond exhausted of having to relive the same playoff nightmare year after year with no sign of things trending in the right direction. This is a fanbase that has had to endure 58 years without a Stanley Cup win, 23 years without a third-round appearance, and seven consecutive Game 7 losses. The last five Game 7 defeats saw the Leafs only muster up one goal in each game, with the last time they scored more than once being in 2018. All this while boasting four of the most talented offensive players in the NHL right now, and all they have to show for it are two series wins.
I have already come to terms with the fact that things were never going to be the same for the Leafs, regardless of how the rest of their series against the defending Stanley Cup champions went. I would imagine most would have rooted for the Core Four to finally break through and exorcise their demons, but getting outclassed by the Panthers in the most important game in recent memory made it painfully clear that it&#8217;s long overdue time for meaningful changes.
How exactly things unfold in the weeks and months ahead remains unclear at the time of filing, but there is no denying that opting to run it back again would not go over well with the fanbase. With so much baggage of playoff futility and marginal progress when it matters, the Leafs need to recognize that it is time to try something different and make some fundamental adjustments to their lineup. They have gone through multiple GMs, coaches, and playstyles, yet the common denominator has been the players at the top of the food chain that have failed to deliver when it counts for the better part of a decade.
If the latest Game 7 loss taught us anything, it&#8217;s that Leafs fans are tired of the status quo and deserve better than what they got on Sunday.
<h3>Sponsored by bet365</h3>

The Toronto Maple Leafs fell short in an eighth consecutive winner-take-all game with a 6-1 drumming at the hands of the Florida Panthers.

After working hard to secure <a href="https://theleafsnation.com/news/trying-find-calmess-madness-toronto-maple-leafs-core-four-era" target="_blank" rel="noopener">a shot at redemption</a> on home ice following a 6-1 blowout loss in Game 5, the Leafs instead decided to lay an even bigger egg than they did four nights prior. All the work done in the regular season to secure home ice and progress towards implementing a new playing style vanished as quickly as the Panthers were able to build on their lead, and they did not relinquish.

It was a sight that has become all-too familiar to Leafs fans since the start of the Core Four era: a Game 7 loss where the stars fail to produce, the goalie lets them down, too many defensive blunders, and a lack of authority and desperation. As a result of this latest heartbreak, the fans inside Scotiabank Arena made their point that they are exhausted with having to relieve the same song and dance by raining out boos and tossing debres on the ice such as jerseys.

To know that those scenes came less than two hours after the building was buzzing with an electric atmosphere before puck drop that is not often seen even in the playoffs makes the performance all the more maddening. From the jump, the Leafs were playing as nervously as they have ever been, and it snowballed into the stretch in the second period where things unravelled. There were certainly moments where it looked like the team could break through and change the trajectory of the game, but they once again did not do enough to make Sergei Bobrovsky's job difficult or to plant any seed of doubt in their opponent. If anything, the Panthers were playing more like the team that was trailing 6-1 instead of the actual one.

When things began to spiral, everyone on the ice lost their composure and <a href="https://theleafsnation.com/news/mitch-marner-instructs-toronto-maple-leafs-wake-up-trailing-game-7-florida-panthers" target="_blank" rel="noopener">resorted to yelling at each other</a>. In the immediate aftermath of the game, captain Auston Matthews said there were <a href="https://theleafsnation.com/news/auston-matthews-toronto-maple-leafs-too-many-passengers-game-7" target="_blank" rel="noopener">'too many passengers'.</a> In reflecting on why the Leafs played so horrendously for two straight home games, head coach Craig Berube was at a loss for words when trying to describe why it happened.

https://twitter.com/TLNdc/status/1924276310454505513

This is a core that is running out of answers and running out of time to get things right. This version of the Leafs with Matthews, Mitch Marner, William Nylander, and John Tavares is all but over, with the makeup of the roster expected to look quite different when the 2025-26 season commences in roughly five months from now. Whether that be through trades, free agent signings, or the emergence of prospects such as Easton Cowan, the offseason will likely bring forth significant changes to a team that once again fell short of hockey glory.

It could also spell the end of Brendan Shanahan's tenure, with his longstanding bet that the nucleus will one day break through in the postseason yet again blowing up in his face. Apart from the Core Four and Morgan Rielly, the Leafs' president has been the one constant presence throughout this nearly decade-long nightmare in the postseason. There is no denying that he has done well in building a team that has been successful in the regular season as evidenced by them boasting the longest active playoff streak at nine consecutive appearances. But fans don't care for those stats or the fact that the team won a division title: they want to see meaningful progress in the postseason and a team that at least gives it their all no matter the result.

This is why the Leafs teams of the 1990s and 2000s continued to be revered despite them also falling short in the playoffs, whereas this modern era is being looked at with disdain and disgust. Those teams of old never went down without a fight and gave the fanbase something to be proud of in spite of the loss, while the current iterations withered under the pressure and played timidly to allow their opponent a chance at dictating the pace.

It's no wonder that things unravelled into a circus during the third period of Game 7 because Leafs fans are beyond exhausted of having to relive the same playoff nightmare year after year with no sign of things trending in the right direction. This is a fanbase that has had to endure 58 years without a Stanley Cup win, 23 years without a third-round appearance, and seven consecutive Game 7 losses. The last five Game 7 defeats saw the Leafs only muster up one goal in each game, with the last time they scored more than once being in 2018. All this while boasting four of the most talented offensive players in the NHL right now, and all they have to show for it are two series wins.

I have already come to terms with the fact that things were never going to be the same for the Leafs, regardless of how the rest of their series against the defending Stanley Cup champions went. I would imagine most would have rooted for the Core Four to finally break through and exorcise their demons, but getting outclassed by the Panthers in the most important game in recent memory made it painfully clear that it's long overdue time for meaningful changes.

How exactly things unfold in the weeks and months ahead remains unclear at the time of filing, but there is no denying that opting to run it back again would not go over well with the fanbase. With so much baggage of playoff futility and marginal progress when it matters, the Leafs need to recognize that it is time to try something different and make some fundamental adjustments to their lineup. They have gone through multiple GMs, coaches, and playstyles, yet the common denominator has been the players at the top of the food chain that have failed to deliver when it counts for the better part of a decade.

If the latest Game 7 loss taught us anything, it's that Leafs fans are tired of the status quo and deserve better than what they got on Sunday.
<h3>Sponsored by bet365</h3>

Recent articles from Michael Mazzei

Breaking News