The LeafsNation has no direct affiliation to the Toronto Maple Leafs, Maple Leaf Sports & Entertainment, NHL, or NHLPA
Why the Leafs should temporarily ignore north-south hockey to continue offensive surge
alt
Photo credit: Sergei Belski-Imagn Images
Arun Srinivasan
Feb 6, 2025, 14:30 ESTUpdated: Feb 6, 2025, 14:23 EST
Toronto Maple Leafs head coach Craig Berube is on a mission to revamp his team’s style of play during his first year with the club and thus far, it has largely worked. Under Berube’s supervision, Toronto has morphed into a club that prioritizes simplicity, with an adherence to ‘north-south’ hockey, as the team plays with vertical lines and often pursues the puck through dump-and-chase, rather than maintaining possession at all costs.
Although the Maple Leafs have committed to sound defensive structure, it hasn’t been perfect as the team was getting torched off the rush through December and January, Morgan Rielly is showing diminishing returns (although he responded with an excellent performance in Tuesday’s 6-3 win over the Calgary Flames) and Toronto’s offence has largely dried up at 5-0n-5. Last season, the Maple Leafs led the NHL with 200 goals at 5-on-5. This year, Toronto is tied for 14th with the Montreal Canadiens, Los Angeles Kings and New York Islanders ahead of Thursday’s games, with 105 goals at 5-on-5.
Considering that the Maple Leafs boast some of the greatest offensive talent in the NHL, this is a nearly untenable outcome. And while Berube’s adherence to north-south hockey could prove instrumental during the playoffs, Toronto broke out of its rigid structure against the Edmonton Oilers on Saturday, and again during Tuesday’s comprehensive win against the Calgary Flames, which helped unlock its offensive potential.
Mike Kelly of NHL Network found that the Maple Leafs rank 27th in rush chances per game, while ranking first in goals per game off the rush in the league. This isn’t particularly surprising, but it encourages the Maple Leafs to occasionally break structure and become more inventive when their opponent can’t contain the neural zone. William Nylander likely leads the NHL in breakaway chances — any casual observer of the league has noticed that Nylander seemingly slips behind the defence once every two games at minimum — while Bobby McMann’s elite straight-line speed has paid dividends during a breakout campaign. Auston Matthews can excel in any offensive situation and ranks within the top 100 in rush attempts at 5-on-5 despite missing 15 games, as he can power through defenders while entering the offensive zone.
Nylander and McMann are both adept at punishing teams for making mistakes, when they’re encouraged to use space in the neutral zone and attack liberally. Here are two examples from Tuesday’s win, where the Maple Leafs convert defence into instant offence — to say nothing of Nylander stripping MacKenzie Weegar of the puck for a game-sealing hat-trick with the empty net.
And here’s a bonus example, when Matthews picked off an errant Flames pass, charged up the ice, and Matthew Knies cleaned up the rebound. Toronto played freely, it emphasized puck possession at all costs and ripped into a Calgary team that is fighting valiantly for a wild-card spot.
Risk aversion in the playoffs is a necessary detail, to be clear. Berube was brought in, in large part due to the fact that his preferred style of play is diametrically opposite to Sheldon Keefe’s free-wheeling offence, that allows Nylander, Matthews and company to showcase the variety of their scintillating skill set. And this isn’t also meant to preach taking risks at all costs, either. Toronto’s sound defensive principles ought to go a long way, but a strict adherence to Berube’s system when the goals aren’t flowing doesn’t make a ton of sense either. If the worry is about how the team will score during the playoffs, breaking out of rigid structure, temporarily, may be the key.
We don’t want to be revisionist, either. Toronto won Saturday’s thriller against Edmonton because of Joseph Woll’s heroics in net, but it did play a free-form style of play against one of the NHL’s most dangerous teams which boasts two Hart Trophy winners in Leon Draisaitl and Connor McDavid.
Mitch Marner is a player who embodies two-way excellence, and is two years removed from a Selke finalist nomination. He’s also at his best offensively when he’s allowed to create freely, and he scored an outright sensational goal off the rush against the Oilers to start the third period on Saturday, which stood as the game-winner.
If the regular season is meant to be an audition for the playoffs, then the Maple Leafs have acquitted themselves well. The past two games have allowed the Maple Leafs to find their flow at 5-on-5, and the power play is converting at a 32.4 percent clip since January 1. This could be instructive to players like Max Domi and Nick Robertson as well, who have often struggled to find their offence — Domi especially — while adapting to a style of play that dictates Toronto play in vertical lines, hounding down pucks after getting through the neutral zone.
Berube and his staff won’t want to hear it, and we’ll defer to them when it comes to tactics, but a temporary break from structure has unlocked some strong offensive results for the Maple Leafs. It’ll be compelling to see whether this approach continues after the 4 Nations Face-Off break.

Sponsored by bet365