What a difference a week makes for the Toronto Maple Leafs. Ahead of Tuesday’s draft lottery, many Maple Leafs fans were bracing for the worst-case scenario in which the team’s first-round pick would convert to the Boston Bruins. Mats Sundin and John Chayka were introduced on Monday to a partially hostile audience, tasked with an insoluble goal of returning this Maple Leafs’ roster back to contention. After sporting 8.5 percent odds, the lottery balls returned a 7-2-11-12 combination, affording the Maple Leafs the first overall pick in the 2026 NHL Draft.

For a large faction of the wide-spanning Leafs Nation, it was a return to hope. There can be a misguided notion about the Maple Leafs’ fan base from the outside looking in. Although the Maple Leafs boast the largest fan base in the NHL, it’s not an inelastic support: fans have grown tired of the team’s propensity to fall flat in the playoffs, combined with outrageous ticket prices and fan services. When you look eastbound, the Montreal Canadiens’ fan base displays enthusiastic, unconditional support for their team, and their playoff atmosphere has been the envy of professional sports. Scotiabank Arena, by comparison, is a library. It’s now incumbent upon MLSE CEO Keith Pelley to create a less sterile environment for fans, while realizing the crown jewel of the company has been extended a lifeline.

Gavin McKenna is the type of prospect that can eradicate encrusted skepticism. He’s been likened to Nikita Kucherov and Patrick Kane, and provides the Maple Leafs with a ready-made top-six forward. After a season where the Maple Leafs experienced a 30-point dropoff, and the fan base continued to sour on the existing core, McKenna will be a breath of fresh air for a jaded supporters’ section. Toronto’s fans are well aware that the team needs to catch up to Montreal and Buffalo in the Atlantic, while needing to overhaul its defence corps entirely, in order to return to contention. McKenna now augments a barren under-25 corps, and provides the Maple Leafs with a big three of sorts, alongside Matthew Knies and Easton Cowan. Leafs fans, at least the ones priced out of the building, are the most intelligent in the NHL, and know when the product doesn’t live up to internal expectations.

There are few places worse than to be stuck in the middle. McKenna provides the Maple Leafs with some flexibility in whatever direction they elect to pursue, and it allows for a clean break from the Core Four era. Ahead of next fall, the Maple Leafs can earnestly sell a vision of optimism and hope, with McKenna at the forefront. If MLSE is aware of what lies ahead, expect the league’s largest, widest-spanning fan base to return in full force.

The Nation Network is your all-access pass to the playoffs. Shows, stats, fantasy insights, live social updates—if it’s happening, we’ve got it. Every goal, every hit, every moment—we break it down for you. One Network. Every moment. Tune in on the Daily Faceoff YouTube channel!